Register now Essentials of Product Management - Sydney – 5 September 2016

Project Manager vs Product Manager

465 Flares Twitter 40 Facebook 22 LinkedIn 397 Google+ 6 Email -- Email to a friend 465 Flares ×

One of the key challenges that we hear when we talk to PRODUCT Managers is that they are often expected to perform the role of PROJECT Manager for some or all of the delivery of their product to the marketplace.

On the “Brainmates – Product Management People” LinkedIn group, Tom Adler posted the following question to find out the difference:

“I know that Product Managers are often asked to be Project Managers. Are Project Managers often asked to be Product Managers?”.

This generated a lot of reactions, mostly questioning whether one person can effectively fulfil both roles at the same time.
Here hare a few of the comments posted:

  • Scot Sehlhorst:

    “For me, the difference is simple. Project management has the following area of focus: “when”. Product management has the following area of focus: “why” Can one person be held accountable for both? Sure.”

  • Irene Liakos:

    “A project manager’s role is very different from a product manager. Using the same person as product and project manager does justice to neither role.”

  • Chris Dahl:

    “It also depends on the person, and the size of the business. In startup/DMB environment I’m sure there are situations where both roles are performed by the one person, and to an acceptable level. Agree the ideal situation is to break it out into two different roles, but it can work when still small”

At Brainmates we treat these two roles as fundamentally different, yet interrelated roles. As a reaction to this discussion we wanted to elaborate more on the interaction of these roles and sat down with Damian Haslam, Project Manager at Vodafone.

Product Manager vs Project Manager: The Brainmates perspective

The first challenge in differentiating the role of Project Manager or a Product Manager is that they sound a lot alike. While it is a trivial semantic issue it often leads to confusion about the 2 roles. It’s important to begin with the definition of the words Product and Project.

  • PROJECT: A project is a temporary endeavour undertaken to create a unique product, service, or result [1].
  • PRODUCT: A product is anything that can be offered to a market that might satisfy a want or a need [2]. A product has a life cycle. It’s conceived, developed, introduced and managed in the market, and retired when the need for a product diminishes.  A product developed within context of a project is needed to create a product. During the life cycle of a product sometimes multiple projects can occur.

As a result of these definitions we can see that a Project Manager’s focus is internal and tactical whereas a Product Manger’s focus is external on the customers’ need and on the resulting product strategy.

Project Management

A Project Manager is ultimately responsible for a predefined outcome which will be described as the projects objective. They will manage the development of the product, service or result through the application of available resources (including a project team).

Project Management as a discipline provides the tools and techniques for the team to organise and prioritise the various tasks that need to be completed, as well as work within any applicable constraints (including time, cost, and quality). The tools and techniques Project Managers usually employ can be roughly divided into 3 main areas:

  • Risk and issue management is an important aspect of Project Management and serves to highlight and then manage any risks to the project completing successfully, as well as minimising the impact of any issues that are identified.
  • Resource management involves ensuring the project team have what they need, when they need it. That includes such simple things as task lists, materials, infrastructure, reporting and even extra people
  • Scope management is usually the most difficult activity a Project Manager is involved in and involves limiting the extent (scope) of the endeavour within acceptable allowances, usually engaging in a balancing act between the three critical aspects of time, cost and quality. For instance, if the time to deliver the project is reduced then either cost must be increased, or scope reduced to maintain  quality.

Project management is a tactical, time limited activity that is defined by the businesses strategic objectives.

Product Manager

A  Product Managers is responsible for the ongoing satisfaction of unmet needs of customers so it will contribute to the following:

  • More value than the competition
  • Build a sustainable competitive advantage
  • Financial benefit for a business

This includes but also extends beyond the lifecycle of any one product. Managing the product throughout the product lifecycle ensuring that it continues to satisfy market needs includes:

  • Gathering and prioritising product and customer requirements,
  • Defining the product vision,
  • Working closely with engineering,
  • Working with sales, marketing and support to ensure revenue and customer satisfaction goals are met.

The Product Manager’s job also includes ensuring that the product and marketing efforts support the company’s overall strategy and goals. A Product Manager tries to find out the customers’ needs and develop a product to satisfy them.

Product Management DEFINES the strategic business objectives that initiate discrete projects.

Role Overlap

It’s evident that the roles of a Project Manager and a Product Manager are very different but these roles have a similar skill set.

  • Excellent organisational and interpersonal skills
  • Leadership qualities
  • Time management

So it is not uncommon for organisations to ask Product Managers to take on Project Management responsibility and vice versa.

Resulting Problems

We see that doing both jobs can compromise the successful delivery of a project

  • If a Product Manager is also running a project his/her time and attention for the customer strategy gets diverted to chasing people, reporting etc.
  • You do not have the sufficient skill set to perform well on all points. A Project Manager excels at managing to datelines and a Product Manager knows what the customer wants and keeps that in mind.
  • Wearing both hats with different objectives sometimes results in a conflict of interest.

How Can We Manage These Problems?

In some situations it may still be feasible to have the Product Manager also undertake the Project Management role. However it is always ideal to have these two roles done by two individuals. Depending on the following factors, it is good to recommend that both Project Manger and Product Manager roles will be carried out by two individuals to successfully complete a project and launch a good product:

  • Large size project
  • Multiple involved departments and stakeholders
  • Longer delivery time line
  • Multiple geographic  locations
  • Big team (i.e. 5+ people to co-ordinate)

“Project Manager vs Product Manager Detector”

Brainmates has developed  a simple tool to identify if you are doing the job of a Product Manager or a Project Manager.  The tool contains a set of questions and a results presentation grid. The grid provides a visual overview to help you determine if you are doing the job of a Product Manager or Project Manager. Your questionnaire scores will determine the colours displayed on the presentation grid.  for example, if an activity displays the colour PINK it means that you are doing a task that is not part of the core focus of your role.

In the example below the Product Manager has been doing a couple of the Project Manager’s tasks. The Product Manager’s tasks are shown on the left side of the grid. The right side of the grid shows the Project Mangers tasks. On the grid below a couple of tasks are coloured PINK. This indicates that the Product Manager has fulfilled tasks that he/she ideally should not be doing. We can also see that some Product Managers tasks are PURPLE. This indicates that the Product Manager is not able to complete his/her own required tasks.

The tool can be downloaded here and we would love to get your feedback and ideas on how to improve it.

Summary

Having both a Project Manager and a Product Manager will contribute to the successful launch of a product in a positive way.  Derek Morrison provides the perfect metaphor:

“A Project Manager is like a mid wife- he/she delivers the baby, hands it over to the mother and moves on. The baby being the product and the mother being the Product Manager”

It is not a question of one or the other. Both the Product Manager and the Project Manager roles are required for long term business success.

References:

  • [1] Project Management Institute (2004). A Guide to the Project Management Body of Knowledge: PMBOK Guide. 3rd Edition. Newtown Square, Pennsylvania, Project Management Institute, p. 5.
  • [2] Kotler, P., Armstrong, G., Brown, L., and Adam, S. (2006) Marketing, 7th Ed. Pearson Education Australia/Prentice Hall.
Please add your feedback in the comments below.

Visited 101159 times.

At Brainmates we love Product Managers and love helping them deliver awesome products to their customers. If you are in a Product Management role, then we are here to help you.

Join us at our next training course :

Next Course Dates Duration Location Price Status
Essentials of Product Management 5-Sep-16 3 days Sydney $2,995.00 Register

We can also help you with other courses, free talks, coaching and workshop facilitation.

You should stay in touch with us via our monthly newsletter.

Or just call us. We are really nice. +61 1800 BRAINMATES (1800 272 466)

20 Comments

  • Good definitions. For me, a proDUCT manager works with the product throughout its lifecycle; a proJECT manager works with a project through a single development cycle or cycles. And I agree with Scott: proJECT is about WHEN.

    For my take on titles, see “Managers as Experts” at http://www.pragmaticmarketing.com/publications/topics/06/0603sj


  • And to revise Derek’s point:
    proJECT manager = midwife;
    proDUCT manager = father;
    Development manager = mother.

    I think most of us would agree that the dev team and the mother both create the product, while the product manager and father are involved in planning and nurturing.


  • Adrienne says:

    In this case Steve, there are 2 Product Managers, the Mother and the Father!


  • Yossi says:

    I’d like to modify the above “WH questions” definitions:
    – Product Manager – Functionality wise (Customer/Application domain):
    What the market needs, What should the system do & When (window of opportunity), When ready (due to his colleague – the Project Manager) – What is to be done for proper product introduction, sales & customer training/support
    – Product Manager – Technologically wise (R&D/Manufacturing/tech support domain):
    How will the system look like, Who will do what, How much $$$ is to be spent, When it will be ready (time to market) and in What level of maturity


  • Emma says:

    Great definitions and clarifications.

    I’d like to add another question into the mix, assuming the roles as they have been described above.

    Who is ultimately reponsible for the product? Is the Product Manager answerable to the Project Manager or vice versa?

    Who is the one source of truth for all information during the development of the product?


  • Yossi says:

    AS of my experience: The proJECT mngr takes care for the product until its “death” (even in mid organizations that have
    a Production-Engineering dep.)/ It includes modifications & SW releases.

    I’d like to modify the above “WH questions” definitions:
    – ProDUCT Manager – Functionality wise (Customer/Application domain):
    What the market needs, What should the system do & When (window of opportunity), When ready (due to his colleague – the Project Manager) – What is to be done for proper product introduction, sales & customer training/support
    – ProJECT Manager – Technologically wise (R&D/Manufacturing/tech support domain):
    How will the system look like, Who will do what, How much $$$ is to be spent, When it will be ready (time to market) and in What level of maturity


  • This happens all too often, and can become quite overwhelming for a product manager asked to become a temporary project manager! – A more likely role would be that of a project minder, with a dedicated manager in charge.


  • Emma – From my experience (as a product manager), the Product Manager is ultimately responsible for the product, just as a parent is ultimately responsible for the child (borrowing from above analogies).

    The product manager also has ultimate say on “truth” (if you mean what I think you mean). It is the Product Manager’s job to know the priorities and benefits of marketing this product in the first place. Or from a different angle, If the proDUCT manager decides that there are no longer any business reasons to release a product in development, the proJECT manager can not overrule and insist they finish the project anyway.


  • Subrat says:

    Hi all,
    Thnkzz for the wonderful info.


  • Subrat says:

    Hi All,
    I am working as an Associate S/W Engg. in a MNC from approx. to be 1yr and i aspire to be a good Project Manager.
    Really this blog in a short-time helped me a lot to understand, behind the scenes of management.
    I am a completely new seed to this area but with all my will, interest and power is ready to jump into this.
    Was wandering if i can get any personal email address to have advices from the real-time project managers who can guide me as a mentor and let me get loaded to have a blast as a Project Manager.
    Please help me if possible to get hold and relish my dreams.

    Best Regards,
    Subrat 🙂


  • Nico says:

    Thanks for the post and for the tool.
    Has been very useful to understand the connections and/or gaps between these 2. I am a Project manager to whom has been offered a Product Portfolio Manager position.


  • Jatin Kathuria says:

    Clear, Crisp and very enlightening. thanks.


  • Webniche says:

    As some one mentioned above smaller companies cannot always afford the expense of both a Product Manager and a Project Manager. I believe if you have passion for the product it is very easy for the project manager to fulfill both roles


  • Dimitris says:

    I completely agree. Product management is broader than project management as far as the job requirements is concerned. Product management is horizontal including sale of the product, technology, legal, business model, positioning, branding, and marketing of the product etc. whereas project management is vertical including scoping, developing, monitoring and delivering.


  • hatem salih says:

    Due to the nature of product management processes, I do not think a project manager can be a product manager for:-
    – project management processes, tools and techniques are the same for all projects. While product management processes are product- specific. a software project implements the same processes of building a bridge. while developing a software processes (pmbok project life cycles) widely differs from building that bridge.
    – building product process is different and uses different T&Ts that applys only for building the same project.
    – both use quality assurance and quality control but in both cases (QA&QC) targets the product QA and the processes that results in it QC.
    – managing product needs product- specifi skills. it is not necessary that product manager have project management skills. someone else may help him but not anyone can rake over from him unless has the same skilles. this isn’ t the case in project management. any person with general project management skills can take over. hope these personal assumptions helps.


  • Muhammad Shakil says:

    hi,

    You are responsible for a portfolio of products that have been in market for some time and have an established customer base. Your practical addressable market shows little to negative growth. What are the key product management differences in working with mature products such as these versus launching new products?

    Regards.


Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *